Missy Whynaught by Elizabeth Ball

Reviewed by Ian Thomas Shaw
Once again, Montreal's Baraka Books has released a fascinating novel that reflects the direction the press has taken under its new fiction editor, Leila Marshy. Missy Whynaught is both heartbreaking and darkly comic. Author Elizabeth Ball takes readers on an unconventional journey through the life of a young woman who seeks love in all the wrong places and repeatedly collides with the shortcomings of those around her.
The novel is set primarily in New Brunswick, with significant sections taking place in Cuba, where Pup, Missy's father, has holed up for years. It chronicles Missy's journey from childhood to early adulthood.
Poverty and social class are ever-present themes, and Missy's family circumstances are complicated, to say the least. Her father is an appealing but unreliable presence, while her relationship with her mother is marked by a particularly uncompromising form of tough love. Caught between these two conflicting influences, Missy grows up trying to make sense of love, loyalty and her own self-worth.
It is perhaps this emotional uncertainty that makes Missy such an interesting protagonist. She is vulnerable, impulsive and sometimes exasperating, repeatedly drawn towards relationships that promise affection but deliver disappointment. More troublingly, she never seems to learn from her mistakes. Despite the darker aspects of Missy's life, Ball overlays the narrative with considerable humour, making readers care about her unconventional heroine.
At times, however, Missy's own story is pushed to the sidelines by that of her father, Pup. Mercurial and charismatic, this man-child's influence on Missy raises difficult questions about parental responsibility and the lasting consequences of childhood neglect. Their relationship illustrates just how powerful the need for parental approval can become when that approval is withheld during a child's formative years.
A turning point comes when eighteen-year-old Missy visits Pup in Cuba, where he has spent years enjoying a seemingly carefree existence of cheap rum and unrestrained promiscuity. What initially appears to be an escape into an exotic, alternative world becomes an opportunity to examine privilege, inequality and the complicated relationship between Western expatriates and the societies in which they establish themselves. This expansion of the novel's perspective is one of its more ambitious features. Ball is interested not only in the private disappointments of an individual but also in the social structures that shape people's opportunities and relationships.
The novel gradually shifts from portraying Missy as a victim of neglect to exploring the complicated business of becoming oneself when the people who are supposed to provide guidance and security repeatedly fall short. Missy is more often than not her own worst enemy, allowing the desire for affection to compromise judgment and blur the boundaries between love and dependency.
Ball offers no easy answers or neatly packaged redemption. Instead, she gives readers an imperfect young woman whose struggles are recognizably human. Missy's journey may be messy, uncomfortable and occasionally outrageous, but it is precisely this chaos that makes her story shine.


Comments