A Curious Presence by Margo MacDonald

Reviewed by Wendy Hawkin
This absorbing book is subtitled: An Exploration of Ghosts and the People Who Haunt Them. If that sounds paradoxical, settle into MacDonald’s book with an open mind. I promise, she will take you on a journey that may leave you feeling unsettled, but that also may inspire deep thought into the realm of possibility.
Rather than write a sensational ghost-busting thriller, MacDonald chooses to present a series of interviews with seasoned paranormal investigators whom she meets at various haunted locales in Canada, the US, and the UK. Most of these real-life investigators are skeptics with changing beliefs due to the kind of work they do and their eerie experiences. Their stories and opinions may surprise you. This is no ghostbusters.
Well-researched and verging on the academic, the book is both a travelogue and compendium of paranormal knowledge. Some of these haunted locales might even make it to your bucket list, as they have mine. For example, I’m drawn to The Shambles, an infamous street in York, UK, with its “preserved and half-timbered buildings, the twisted passageway, and the overhangs that blocks out almost all the light overhead.” The lane was the haunt of slaughterhouses and butchers from 1080 until the 1930s, and the “two deep runnels down the centre of the cobbled street [were] needed to drain all the blood” (138). Nearby pubs sport macabre decor to suit this landmark of “dark tourism.”
In York, MacDonald takes in a ghost tour and hears an amazing story once relayed by Harry Martindale, a young plumber who, while working in the cellar in 1953, saw a troupe of Roman soldiers appear from a wall beside him. The tale is long and detailed, but if you’re curious, you can find his interviews online and watch this ghost tour for a retelling. At the Golden Fleece (1668), known as “England’s Most Haunted Inn,” she spends the night alone. In fact, once the downstairs pub closes, she’s locked in the building with just one other couple. The fact sheet says, “fifteen different ghosts haunt the place.” Using the “spirit box”, MacDonald attempts to contact ghosts and reports her conversations.
With sixteen chapters of in-depth storytelling, MacDonald takes us on a foray into some famous ghostly locales. One of the most intriguing concerns The Stanley Hotel in Estes Park, Colorado. Stephen King wrote The Shining after staying there in 1974. MacDonald interviews Connor and Karl, partners who invented “The Estes Method” of paranormal investigation and worked there from 2009 to 2016. The theory behind their methodology is to limit sensory input on the person receiving by fitting them with a blindfold and headphones. This induces a meditative or hypnagogic state. The other investigator asks questions aloud with the hope that the entity will answer. Unaware of whatever else is happening in the room, including the questions, the receiver repeats or describes whatever they hear through a modified AM-FM radio called a “spirit box.” Do the spirits speak? Well, yes and no.
The question MacDonald asks throughout is “who or what are these entities?” Contrary to some popular beliefs, Connor says: “I don’t think it’s dead people.” What follows is a profound discussion as to what they actually might be, and that definition involves us humans and our subconscious mind. This takes ghost-study out of the realm of religion and into that of modern psychology. If there was no one to be haunted, would there actually be a ghost at all?
For twenty-five years, Margo has worked as a storyteller and paranormal investigator and consultant for The Haunted Walk, a tour company who offers ghost tours laced with history in Kingston, Toronto, and Ottawa. She’s also an award-winning performer and writes plays inspired by queer women’s history. Coming originally from Ottawa, Margo now lives in Toronto. To hear MacDonald talk with Jim Dean (Creative Director of the Haunted Walk and Host of the Haunted Talks podcast), listen here.
For those of you residing near Ottawa, the Haunted Walk gives tours of the Mackenzie King Estate in Gatineau Park, Chelsea Quebec. The property (a 231-hectare estate on Kingsmere Lake) was the haunt of Canada’s Liberal Prime Minister from 1921-1930 and again from 1935-1948. King was also a spiritualist who held seances and according to MacDonald, “all the houses connected with him, now preserved as museums, are haunted.” In fact “the most commonly sighted ghost is Mackenzie King himself.” Bucket list? Check.
A Curious Presence is published by ECW Press.
W. L. Hawkin writes urban fantasy and romantic suspense. Her latest novel is a paranormal mystery set at a lighthouse in the Pacific Northwest, and yes, there are ghosts.


Comments